January 10, 2024

Craving a Cuban sandwich? Or is succulent jerk chicken on your mind? Maybe it’s rice and peas, or roast pork. Whatever island delicacy you’re in the mood for, there are plenty of places around the city to get your fix—so how can you know which ones won’t disappoint? Here, we’ve rounded up ten of the best Caribbean spots in NYC, according to our editors and online reviews. (Psst: Our picks include a laid-back Puerto Rican joint, an inventive Haitian eatery and a new restaurant by a popular James Beard-awarded chef.)

16 Cozy Restaurants in NYC to Beat the Winter Blues:

1. Kokomo Caribbean Restaurant

• Reservations: Resy
• What to Order: salmon filet, lobster bisque, stuffed plantains, oxtail flatbread

This Williamsburg spot is influenced by various Caribbean nations, and its menu proves it. Offering dinner, drinks and brunch, Kokomo is slinging classics like jerk chicken and modern meals like sweet plantain pancakes alike. “They’re on the pricier side, but I like that they offer flavorful, Caribbean dishes with a healthy spin,” says assistant editor Nakeisha Campbell. Head there on the weekend for tunes by a live DJ.